Fenik's Frozen Custard Logo
  • Home
  • Menu
  • Find Us
  • About

Our Delicious Menu

Handcrafted frozen custard made fresh daily

Note: All flavors are subject to availability and may change daily. Call ahead to confirm your favorite flavor!

Our Signature Flavors

Madagascar Vanilla Bean
Madagascar Vanilla Bean
Our signature custard made with real Madagascar vanilla beans, creating a rich and aromatic experience with visible vanilla specks throughout.
Customer Favorite
$4.99
Double Chocolate
Double Chocolate Decadence
Indulgent chocolate custard made with premium Belgian cocoa and folded with dark chocolate chips for the ultimate chocolate lover's dream.
$5.49
Superman
Superman
A nostalgic Midwest favorite featuring swirls of blue moon, cherry, and lemon custard that creates a colorful and delicious treat.
Local Favorite
$5.99
Strawberry Fields
Fresh Strawberry Fields
Made with fresh, locally-sourced strawberries when in season, this custard features real fruit pieces and natural strawberry flavor.
$5.49
Cookies and Cream
Cookies & Cream Dream
Vanilla custard loaded with chunks of chocolate sandwich cookies, creating the perfect balance of creamy and crunchy textures.
$5.99
Butter Pecan
Butter Pecan Bliss
Rich butter-flavored custard with roasted pecans, offering a sophisticated taste that's both nutty and sweet.
$5.99

Plant-Based Delights

Enjoy the same creamy texture and delicious flavors in our dairy-free alternatives, perfect for those with dietary restrictions or preferences.

Soy Vanilla
Creamy Soy Vanilla
Smooth and creamy soy-based frozen dessert with natural vanilla flavoring, proving that dairy-free can be just as delicious.
Vegan
$5.99
Coconut
Tropical Coconut Paradise
Rich coconut-based frozen dessert with real coconut flakes, transporting you to a tropical paradise with every bite.
Vegan
$6.49
Almond Peanut Butter
Almond Peanut Butter Swirl
Creamy almond-based frozen dessert swirled with natural peanut butter, creating a protein-rich and satisfying treat.
Vegan
$6.99
Oat Chocolate
Oat Milk Chocolate
Made with creamy oat milk and rich cocoa, this chocolate frozen dessert is indulgent and environmentally conscious.
Vegan
$6.49

Seasonal Specials & Limited Time Offers

These special flavors rotate throughout the year, featuring seasonal ingredients and holiday-inspired creations.

Pumpkin Spice
Autumn Pumpkin Spice
Fall favorite featuring real pumpkin puree and warm spices like cinnamon, nutmeg, and clove. Available September through November.
Fall Special
$6.49
Peppermint Bark
Holiday Peppermint Bark
Festive chocolate custard with crushed peppermint candies and white chocolate chunks. Perfect for the holiday season.
Holiday Special
$6.99
Lemon Berry
Summer Lemon Berry Burst
Refreshing lemon custard with fresh blueberries and strawberries. A perfect summer treat that's both tart and sweet.
Summer Special
$6.49
Maple Walnut
Ohio Maple Walnut
Made with pure Ohio maple syrup and locally-sourced walnuts, celebrating the flavors of our beautiful state.
Local Pride
$6.99

Size Options

Kids Scoop

Perfect for little ones

Starting at $3.99

Regular

Our most popular size

As listed above

Large

For serious custard lovers

Add $1.50

Pint to Go

Take home your favorite

$8.99

Can't Decide?

Ask our friendly staff for a sample! We're always happy to help you find your new favorite flavor.

Visit Us Today

© 2025 Fenik's Frozen Custard. All rights reserved.

Serving Avon Lake and surrounding communities since 2005

Facebook