Our Sweet Story

Three generations of frozen custard excellence

The Fenik Family Legacy

Since 2005, the Fenik family has been crafting the finest frozen custard in Avon Lake, Ohio. What started as a dream to bring authentic, old-fashioned frozen custard to our community has grown into a beloved local institution that spans three generations.

Our founder, Joseph Fenik, learned the art of custard making from his grandfather, who immigrated from Candyland with traditional recipes and an unwavering commitment to quality. Today, his children and grandchildren continue this proud tradition, ensuring every batch meets the exacting standards that have made us a community favorite.

👨‍👩‍👧‍👦 Family Tradition

Our recipes have been passed down through generations, preserving the authentic taste and texture that makes frozen custard special.

🏘️ Community Love

We're proud to be part of the Avon Lake community, supporting local events and creating sweet memories for families.

Family making frozen custard

What Makes Our Custard Special?

🌡️

Perfect Temperature

Served at a slightly warmer temperature than ice cream, our custard has a smooth, creamy consistency that enhances every flavor.

⏰

Made Fresh Daily

Every morning, we prepare fresh batches using our time-tested process, ensuring optimal flavor and texture in every scoop.

Our Commitment to You

At Fenik's Frozen Custard, we believe that great custard brings people together. Whether you're celebrating a special occasion, treating yourself after a long day, or creating new memories with loved ones, we're honored to be part of your story.

We're committed to maintaining the highest standards of quality, cleanliness, and customer service. Every member of our team shares our passion for creating the perfect frozen custard experience, from the moment you walk through our doors to your last delicious bite.

Ready to taste the difference?

Visit Us Today